Blog 16 · mentoring designers

A critique improves a screen. Mentoring improves the person who made it.

Pranjal Chawan
Pranjal ChawanUX leader · LinkedIn

The most valuable feedback I ever give a designer may have nothing to do with their design.

Teams spend hours discussing spacing, flows and components. Those conversations matter. But a designer's career often stalls for different reasons. They can solve the problem and cannot explain the solution. They know something is wrong and stay silent in the meeting. They do great work, then watch someone else present it.

A redline will not fix any of that.

What mentoring looks like from the other side

Rahul Shaligram, who reported to me and is now a Senior Consultant at Capgemini, described it better than I could:

One of the most valuable things I learned from him was to confidently present my ideas — he helped me build the confidence to present my work in front of a team of 70+ members.

Reetika Vyas, now an Assistant Manager at Capgemini, also reported to me. She wrote:

I have always looked up to him as a lighthouse — someone who stands strong, provides direction, and guides others through important career decisions.

I am proud of those words, and I am more proud of what those two have done with their careers. A lighthouse is a good image, because it does not steer the ship. It helps the captain see.

I learned mentoring as a business necessity. When I founded my agency, Shubh Creatives, I grew the team from 1 to 17 people. Recruiting, training and developing people were not side tasks. They were how we kept quality high for more than 300 clients.

Six ways I help designers grow

1. Find the person's next step. A junior designer may need better craft. A senior designer may need influence. The same advice will not help both.

2. Ask them to explain the why. Before reviewing a design, I ask what problem it solves and what they rejected. This builds strategic thinking.

3. Rehearse the room. Run through a presentation together. Ask the hard questions a stakeholder will ask. Confidence often comes from having heard the worst question already.

4. Give them real exposure. Let them present their own work. Stand beside them, and step in only if they truly need it.

5. Share your own mistakes. Telling the team about a project where you designed for the wrong audience does more for psychological safety than any poster.

6. Talk about the career, not only the task. Ask where they want to be in two years. Then look for work that moves them closer.

Better critique habits

Good critique can be a form of mentoring if you run it well:

Instead ofTry
I don't like thisWhat goal does this serve?
Change it to thisWhat other options did you consider?
This is wrongWhat would a first-time user do here?
Nice workThis decision worked because...

Specific praise matters as much as specific criticism. People repeat what they understand.

Why business leaders should care

Mentoring is not a soft extra. McKinsey's design research points out that keeping great design talent takes more than money or promotion. People also want meaningful work and connection with the wider design community.

Strong mentors help teams keep people, reduce dependence on one senior designer, and create future leaders.

Questions people ask

How do you mentor a junior designer? Give clear feedback, explain your reasoning, ask them to justify their decisions, and offer steadily larger responsibilities.

What is the difference between a manager and a mentor? A manager is responsible for work and performance. A mentor focuses on a person's growth. The best design managers do both.

Who helped you find your voice?

Most of us can name that person. If you are building a team that needs that kind of support, I would love to talk. Write to pranjal.productmind@gmail.com. Designers looking for advice are welcome too.

© 2026 Pranjal Chawan. All rights reserved.