Blog 03 · competitive benchmarking

Stop copying your competitor's best screen

Pranjal Chawan
Pranjal ChawanUX leader · LinkedIn

You have no idea why that screen exists.

It may be their highest-converting page. It may be a failed experiment nobody has removed. It may solve a problem their customers have and yours do not. Yet teams paste it into a deck, write "best practice" underneath, and call it competitive benchmarking.

That is not research. It is imitation with a cover page.

What competitive benchmarking is for

Good competitive benchmarking answers three questions:

  1. Where are we below the standard customers now expect?
  2. Where do we match everyone, so nothing makes us memorable?
  3. Where could we do something nobody else does?

The first protects you. The third is where strategy begins.

Even strong companies have room to move here. Baymard's checkout benchmark of 60 leading ecommerce sites found that the average site still had 39 potential areas for improvement. Being a big name does not make every screen a good one to copy.

My five-step benchmarking framework

1. Start with a job, not a brand. Compare how people complete a task, such as opening an account. A customer does not experience your product as a list of pages.

2. Choose competitors your users really consider. Include direct rivals, a substitute and one company from another industry. Customers compare you with the best experience they had this week, not only your sector.

3. Score the same criteria every time. I use task steps, clarity of language, effort, trust signals, error recovery and accessibility. A shared scorecard stops the loudest opinion from winning.

4. Walk the real journey. Sign up. Make mistakes. Use a phone. Use a keyboard alone. Screenshots hide the awkward moments that matter most.

5. Add your own users. Benchmarking shows what exists. Only research tells you whether it matters. Put two or three approaches in front of your customers and watch what happens.

Turn the findings into decisions

A benchmark that ends as a slide deck has failed. I sort findings into three groups:

GroupMeaningAction
FixWe are below customer expectationsAdd to the near-term roadmap
MatchBasic expectation, no advantageDo it simply and move on
DifferentiateAn unmet need nobody serves wellInvest and test

Most teams spend too long in the Match column because it feels safe. The real value is in having the confidence to stop there and spend your energy on the Differentiate column.

Why I treat it as one input

I have seen what happens when a team trusts a logical assumption over real behaviour. In our Fixed Deposit project, the real customers turned out to be nothing like the audience we expected. No competitor's screen would have told us that. A benchmark tells you what others built, and only your customers can tell you what they need.

Questions people ask

What is competitive benchmarking in UX? It is a structured comparison of your experience against competitors and other reference products, using the same tasks and criteria.

How often should you run a UX benchmark? Run one before a major redesign or strategy decision, and refresh it when your market changes.

Want a second pair of eyes?

If your competitor analysis has become a folder of screenshots, let's talk about turning it into strategy. Find me at pranjal.productmind@gmail.com. I enjoy this kind of puzzle.

© 2026 Pranjal Chawan. All rights reserved.